Saturday, July 4, 2009

Ponting's real test

Ponting is thought to be greatest Australian test captain ever by many leading analysts. He has led Australian cricket team successfully over last 5 years. Consider this:

  1. Australia's winning percentage of tests under his captaincy is more than any other Australian captain.
  2. He has always led from front by contributing heavily in middle order. His batting record speaks volumes - a batting average of more than 50, more centuries than any other Australian. (He may even go on to become leading century scorer in the world - Most Hundreds in tests)
  3. His team hold the record of winning most tests on the trot.
  4. He was Man of the Series as Australia became the first team in 86 years to achieve an Ashes clean sweep.

Did Ponting make Australia near invincible or was there some other factor in play. Australia was already number 1 test team before Ponting took over. What made them number 1 team? The answer is Steve Waugh.


Ponting took the baton from Steve Waugh as a test captain at the beginning of 2004 (by that time he was already captaining one day side). He not only inherited the captaincy from an extremely successful captain but also inherited hugely talented players. His playing 11 included Warne, McGrath, Gilchrist, Langer, Hayden, Gillespie, Martyn, Lehmann, Lee and Ponting himself. All of them were match winners in their own right and all of them had impressive records. It was next to impossible that anyone could beat the team comprising of these players.

The credit must go to Waugh for making an unbeatable outfit. The players and the team was nurtured by Steve Waugh. All these match winners (except for Lee and Ponting) have since then retired leaving Australian team in dire straits. Neither CA nor Ponting realized what would happen once these were not available. They didn't take any preventive action to fill their places at right time.

Today team is bereft of greats' services and half of the team consists of bunch of inexperienced players. Australia started losing there domination near the end of 2007. 2008 was the worst year for them in recent history - they lost test series to India and SA.

It is true that Ponting has services of Clarke and Hussey but apart from them there is no one in the team who can match the previous team's greats. It is also true that they won the test series again SA in their own backyard with new players. But the real test for Ponting has already begun.

  1. Can Ponting leave behind a good team to relive the great moments?
  2. Can he create a near invincible team?
  3. Can he relive Waugh's legacy?

Only time will answer these questions. If Ponting is able to successfully lead his team for next two years and pass over a winning combination to next captain (most probably Clarke), history will remember him forever.

2 comments:

  1. Hi, Nice blog Praveen, I absolutely agree with you. It's no big deal to captain a team with Match winners and well established players. I feel the challenging part of captaincy is when you need to build a team from scratch or catch up with players retiring from the squad.

    Tactically, Ponting has never been amongst the greats, he is just an average captain. The only thing which I feel that Ponting deserves credit for is the way he has batted over the past few years despite the pressures of captaincy looming over him. He has become a major force to reckon with for bowlers around the world.

    Regards,

    Venu

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Venu. A captain's character can be seen in advrsity and how well he builds/binds the team together. That is why Ganguly and Smith are considered to be excellent captains.

    ReplyDelete